Suan Cai Recipe (Chinese Pickled Mustard Greens)

ChinesePrep: 20 minCook: 5 minServings: 8

How to make suan cai, the lacto-fermented Chinese pickled mustard greens used in sour soups and stir-fries. Simple brine, no vinegar needed.

Suan cai is the Chinese tradition of lacto-fermented mustard greens, prized for the clean, deep sourness it brings to soups, stir-fries, and braises. It is the vegetable behind suan cai yu (Sichuan sour fish soup) and a staple of Northeastern Chinese home cooking, where whole heads of cabbage or mustard greens are fermented in large crocks to last through the winter.

What is suan cai?

Suan cai (literally “sour vegetable”) refers to mustard greens or cabbage that have been naturally fermented in a salt brine, without vinegar. The salt suppresses harmful bacteria while lactic acid bacteria already present on the vegetable multiply and convert sugars into lactic acid, producing the characteristic sourness over several days to a couple of weeks.

Unlike paocai, which is typically a mix of chopped vegetables in a reusable, heavily spiced brine, suan cai is usually made with a single vegetable, mustard greens or napa cabbage, in a simpler brine with minimal aromatics. The flavor is meant to be clean and sour rather than complex, since suan cai is almost always cooked into another dish rather than eaten on its own straight from the jar.

Suan cai vs. paocai vs. zhacai

These three Chinese pickles are often confused, but each serves a different purpose:

  • Paocai is a mixed-vegetable pickle in a reusable, heavily spiced brine, eaten as a crisp side dish.
  • Suan cai is a single-vegetable ferment, usually mustard greens, with a simple brine, almost always used as a cooking ingredient.
  • Zhacai is a pressed, salted, and dried mustard tuber (the root, not the leaves) that is further seasoned with chili paste, giving it a completely different texture: crunchy rather than soft.

All three rely on the same mustard plant family and similar lactic fermentation, but they diverge in which part of the plant is used and how the final product is meant to be eaten.

Choosing greens

Traditional suan cai uses gai choy, also called potherb mustard or mustard cabbage, which has a assertive, peppery flavor before fermentation that mellows into a rounded sourness. If gai choy is not available, napa cabbage is a reliable substitute and is what most suan cai yu recipes outside China use.

Look for firm, unblemished greens with no yellowing. Older, slightly tougher greens actually hold up better through a long ferment than very tender young greens, which can turn mushy.

Tips for the best suan cai

Wilt before fermenting. Letting the greens air-dry until slightly limp removes surface moisture and lets the salt penetrate more evenly. Skipping this step is the most common reason suan cai turns out too watery.

Keep everything submerged. Any part of the greens exposed to air will mold. A weight is not optional, use a clean stone, a weighted plate, or a water-filled bag to hold the greens under the brine line.

Don’t skip the vinegar or rice wine starter. A small splash is optional but helps the fermentation get going faster and more reliably, especially in cooler kitchens.

Taste before committing. Fermentation speed depends heavily on temperature. Start tasting at day 5 and continue daily until the sourness and texture are where you want them, then refrigerate to slow things down.

Rinse before cooking. Suan cai can be quite salty straight from the jar. A quick rinse under cold water before adding it to soup or a stir-fry balances the seasoning of the final dish.

How to use suan cai

Suan cai is rarely eaten raw. It is typically:

  • Simmered into suan cai yu (sour fish soup) with fish fillets, chilies, and ginger
  • Stir-fried with pork belly or ground pork
  • Added to hot pot for a sour, savory broth base
  • Braised with duck or chicken in Northeastern Chinese cooking

Storage

Once fermented to taste, suan cai keeps in the refrigerator, submerged in its own brine, for up to 2 to 3 months. Always retrieve it with clean, dry utensils. For longer storage, suan cai can also be frozen, though the texture softens slightly after thawing.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Wash the mustard greens thoroughly and let them air-dry for several hours, or up to a full day, until slightly wilted. This reduces excess moisture that would dilute the brine.
  2. Cut the greens into large pieces, roughly 7 to 10cm long. Leave the stems intact if using whole mustard greens.
  3. Bring the water, salt, and sugar to a boil, stirring until fully dissolved. Remove from heat and let cool completely to room temperature.
  4. Pack the wilted greens tightly into a clean glass jar or crock, along with the ginger and dried chilies if using.
  5. Pour the cooled brine over the greens until fully submerged. Add the vinegar or rice wine if using. Weigh the greens down with a clean stone, weight, or a water-filled bag so nothing floats above the brine.
  6. Cover loosely (not airtight) to let fermentation gas escape, or use a jar with an airlock. Keep at room temperature out of direct sunlight.
  7. Ferment for 5 to 10 days, tasting after day 5. The greens are ready when they turn an olive-yellow color and taste pleasantly sour. Move to the refrigerator once fermented to your liking.